Showing posts with label Portugal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Portugal. Show all posts

Sunday, December 2, 2012

Portugal and the welfare state, step 1

A recent article in the Financial Times (Portugal grapples with cost of welfare state) addressed recent statements by the prime minister on the reforms in the public sector.
The starting point was the statement a couple of weeks by the minister of finance on the (apparent) difference between what people want to pay in taxes and the welfare state benefits they want.
The discussion on the role and size of the state and how it is funded (and not the components of the welfare state) is a much needed debate in Portugal. But it cannot be done until February or March if it is  supposed to include the views and desires of the Portuguese population and if its to go beyond cut expenditures across the board.
The challenge for the discussion is how to be cut in terms of what the Government does - not only the always-mentioned quest for efficiency in Government provision of services but also which ones are to be provided by the Government.
This goes beyond knowing which charges people should pay when using Government services. And forces the need for clarification of concepts and roles of Government spending. One the more common errors of perception, which is also present in the financial times article, is people saying they could afford to pay more for health care at point of use - meaning usually that people accept income-based payments at the point of use. Fine. But the mistake is that such charges are usually a very small portion of total funding required, user charges account for less then 2% of total funding needs in the National Health Service. Increasing user charges to cover say 20% would probably lead most people to complain about it. Even the largest single user charge, use of emergency room in central hospitals, is about 10% (or less) of average cost of such episode - this is 20€ user charge mentioned in the FT article. The second aspect of this mistake is conceptual - redistribution  should mainly be done at the funding level, not at the point of use. If there is some correlation between income and need of health care (use), then payments at the point of use according to income may help, but they also destroy the insurance value of protection against uncertainty of health care expenditures. And this role is neglected (wrongly) in most popular statements.
From other areas we are likely to face good arguments for Government intervention, meaning that a careful discussion needs to be made.
Recognizing the importance of this discussion the prime minister said that a baseline proposal for cuts will be provided by February but changes are possible until the Summer, before the next budget proposal is built. This is reasonable. Sets a default situation, and then it is up to the political forces and to society to improve on it. Being too assertive at this stage will not allow for a proper discussion. Let's hope the Portuguese people can do it.


Source | The Portuguese Economy | http://theportugueseeconomy.blogspot.com/2012/12/portugal-and-welfare-state-step-1.html

Wednesday, November 21, 2012

Portugal is in shock

These days, everybody in this country is shocked in a way or another and I am choked in my own way, of course. The reason for all that shock is the Government’s plan to change the social tax (Taxa Social Única), which will lead to an increase in labor's taxation by 7 pp (from 11 to 18%) and a reduction of employers taxation by 5.75 (from 23.5 to 18%; the remaining being an increase of the aggregate from 34.5 to 36%). Such change will imply a massive transfer of wealth from workers to employers, to the tune of 2.2 billion euro annually. But even more shocked I get when I read in the Portuguese press that the IMF's Director, Christine Lagarde, has stated that Portugal is "a success story in the eurozone". Following massive cuts in public wages, massive tax increases, and massive cuts in health, education and unemployment compensations, that success is measured by a 6.6% deficit over GDP, and unemployment estimated to reach 17%, by the end of the year. I wouldn’t call that success. One my just wonder how the 6.6% deficit is esasily compatible with a much lower unemployment rate (12, 13%?, your pick). Both staggering figures are the direct consequence of the way the crisis has been tackled by the close and unhealthy association we have in this country between the troika and the Government. And now everybody is also worried about what will happen politically in the near future.

Source | The Portuguese Economy | http://theportugueseeconomy.blogspot.com/2012/09/portugal-is-in-shock.html

Monday, November 19, 2012

Portugal Real Exchange Rate in the EZ


Flashback
From 1995 to 2001 the large decrease in nominal interest rate (panel 1) fueled an expansion in private expenditure (panel 2) financed with debt (panel 3) while the increase in demand pushed nominal labor compensation to ran a rate of 6 percent per annum, a rate well above labor productivity, and GDP inflation to increase to 4 percent per annum. The result was a large and rapid loss in competitiveness vis-a-vis the eurozone partners (panel 4). During and after the recession of 2002, labor compensation and final prices inflation decelerated, but not sufficiently, and Portugal competitiveness continued to, this time slowly, deteriorate against the other eurozone members (panel 4). (click to enlarge)



Competitiveness
A measure of REER based on ULC vis-a-vis the rest of the eurozone, normalized to 100 in 1995, was at 83.4 in the the fourth quarter 2011 implying a cumulative loss of 16.6 pp. A similar measure based on GDP deflators was at 88.3 implying a cumulative loss of 11.8 pp.

Consequences ?
The observation that the real exchange rates remained misaligned so persistently (the GDP deflator REER moved very little since the starting of the euro) leads to the following question: will the REER have to adjust back to the 1995 level or even overshoot to remedy the accumulated consequences of overvaluation?  One argument for overshooting is that the accumulation of net external debt means that the current account cannot be balanced simply by returning to the initial real exchange rate. Now there is a deficit stemming from the increased debt service (and much lower remittances). Therefore, to restore current account balance, an over-depreciation might be required. However not every model/economist agrees on the necessity of the REER adjustment. Another old dispute.

P.S.
One has to remark that last year current account adjustment has been extraordinary and mainly driven by net exports. An interesting question is to explain how this improvement occurred. 

Source | The Portuguese Economy | http://theportugueseeconomy.blogspot.com/2012/09/portugal-real-exchange-rate-in-ez.html

Friday, November 16, 2012

Statement by the EC, ECB, and IMF on the Fourth Review Mission to Portugal


The program remains on track amidst continued challenges.The authorities are implementing the reform policies broadly as planned and external adjustment is proceeding faster than expected. At the same time, rising unemployment has emerged as a pressing concern. The need to combine fiscal consolidation with deleveraging private balance sheets while restoring external cost competitiveness remains a difficult balancing act. But the authorities are determined to stay the course of adjustment and reform. Broad-based political support and social consensus is a key contribution to a successful adjustment.

Growth in 2012 may hold up better than expected. The rebalancing of the economy has continued, with stronger-than-expected exports more than offsetting weaker domestic demand. GDP in 2012 is now expected to decline by 3 percent (against 3¼ percent before). Positive albeit still subdued growth is expected in 2013. However, with domestic demand weak and pressures on firms to reduce high indebtedness, unemployment has increased sharply as part of the adjustment process, and could peak at close to 16 percent in 2013. Continued tensions in the euro area represent a risk clouding the external outlook.
The ambitious 2012 fiscal deficit target remains within reach. Notwithstanding the weaker labor market and a less tax-friendly growth composition, the authorities expect to achieve the deficit target of 4.5 percent of GDP. As during the third review, new fiscal measures were not discussed, but developments warrant close monitoring to detect potential slippages in a timely manner. The strategy to prevent new and to settle existing arrears is being implemented and regional and local governments under financial stress receive additional support, on the condition of enhancing their own consolidation efforts. Reforms of state-owned enterprises and public-private partnerships are on track. Efforts to strengthen public financial management, bolster tax compliance, and streamline public administration are continuing at good pace.
Protecting the banking system and ensuring orderly deleveraging remain among the program priorities. Liquidity in the banking system continues to benefit from exceptional support from the Eurosystem. The authorities are finalizing efforts to ensure that mid-year targets for banks’ capital buffers will be met. Further progress has also been made in strengthening the banking supervision and resolution frameworks. Tight credit conditions remain a concern and a range of measures is in train to ensure that sound companies, particularly in the tradable sectors, can fund their activities.
Progress is being made on reforms to raise long-term growth. Although product market reforms could still be stepped up in some areas, the program’s structural reform agenda will create the conditions for sustainable growth in productive jobs over the medium term. Reforms are in progress as regards removing rigidities in the housing market, privatizing state companies, making the ports more competitive, and increasing the efficiency of the judicial system. Examples of reforms already legislated include the competition law, the insolvency code, and the urban lease law. Some progress has also been made in reducing the undue burden on consumers and taxpayers by increasing competition and reducing rents in the network and sheltered services sectors, including in the electricity sector. Nevertheless, more determination is needed to push through reforms that touch on sensitive political and vested interests.
The surge in unemployment requires decisive policy action.Temporarily higher unemployment is part of the transition to a more export-oriented economy, but its rise has been exacerbated by Portugal’s long-standing labor market rigidities. The recent approval of the revised Labor Code should attenuate job losses. The broader structural reform agenda and rising capacity utilization in the export sector should help employment recover in the medium term. Nevertheless, further action to improve the functioning of the labor market is urgent. This includes institutional reforms that give firms more flexibility in matching labor costs and productivity. The exceptionally high unemployment, particularly among the young, also calls for more immediate measures, including active labor market policies. We also welcome the government’s initiative to consider, in the context of the budget 2013, ways to reduce social security contributions targeting specific segments of the labor force.
Overall, this review confirms that the program is making good progress amid continued strong external support. Provided that the authorities persevere with strict program implementation, the euro area member states have declared they stand ready to support Portugal until market access is regained. The efforts of the Portuguese authorities are being complemented by a strengthened EU economic policy framework and new EU initiatives to support growth and employment in Portugal, and in Europe as a whole.
The government’s program is supported by loans from the European Union amounting to €52 billion and a €26 billion Extended Fund Facility with the IMF. Approval of the conclusion of this review will allow the disbursement of €4.1 billion (€2.7 billion by the EU, and €1.4 billion by the IMF). These disbursements could take place in July subject to the approval of the IMF Executive Board and ECOFIN and EUROGROUP. The joint mission for the next program review is expected to take place in September 2012.

Source | International Monetary Fund - Blog NEWS | http://imf-news.blogspot.com/2012/06/statement-by-ec-ecb-and-imf-on-fourth.html