Howard Marks was on Bloomberg TV yesterday and it was a great interview. I think Bloomberg TV is way better than CNBC these days as they seem to ask better questions and give the guests more time to answer questions (rather than trying to make them say things that the interviewer wants to hear, or force / trick them into supporting a political view).
Anyway, any time you can hear someone like Marks speak, it's worth your time. Here's the link:
Howard Marks on Bloomberg TV
This blog is not about posting links so you know more is coming.
I don't intend to summarize the interview or anything like that. There were a couple of points in the interview that really struck me and I wanted to point that out. If you have followed and read Marks over the years, you know he is a really solid guy and very credible. So I found it interesting that he said:
Central Bank Actions Reasonable
He was asked if recent central bank actions were a mistake and he said no. He said the Fed is stimulative and it's appropriate that they are stimulative. He said that "their course is reasonable". I think Buffett is on that side too, defending the Treasury and the Fed in their actions in preventing an economic collapse.
Anyway, I tend to be on that side too so it's refreshing to hear people on this side (instead of the Fed bashers which seem to be the majority these days).
Macro-forecasting Bubble
Ever since the financial crisis (and actually from before then, but a lot more since then), a major pet peeve of mine has been what I think is a big macro-forecasting bubble. Reading letters from value investors, I got so tired of reading about the macro. Many equity fund letters spend so much time talking about the debt, the crisis, the coming depression if politicians don't get their act together etc.
Others blamed their poor performance on the macro environment, saying that their mistake was ignoring the macro environment.
I have always thought that the equity funds that lost a lot of money lost money on poor securities analysis; Buffett's portfolio didn't blow up despite being heavy into financials and Buffett didn't sell down his stocks, buy puts, hedge or anything like that at all. He just stuck to strong balance sheets and he did just fine, thank you.
Others jumped into AIG, MER, BSC, LEH, FNM, FRE and suffered permanent loss of capital.
I would call that a securities analysis error, not a macro forecasting error.
But I still keep hearing stock experts spending so much time on the macro.
There's a difference between buying into risky, leveraged institutions and hoping that a recession won't get too bad, or just buying the strongest companies and not worrying about how bad a recession can get secure in the knowledge that the company you own can cope with everything but maybe the moon crashing into the earth (this is a Jamie Dimon scenario when asked if JPM can lose billion or whatever it was during the congressional hearings).
Buffett has said over and over that he doesn't pay attention to the macro when evaluating investments. If he likes the business and the price, he doesn't check to see if the economic forecast is going to be OK. He doesn't worry about what will happen in Europe. He said he has never *not* done a deal or bought a stock due to macro concerns.
Marks on Macro
So anyway, it was very refreshing to hear Marks talk about the macro. He was asked about how macro is getting to be more important in investing in these volatile times. He said that most people think macro will determine investment results (so they pay a lot of attention to it). But he points out that in investing, there is always another side to it.
Of course, it's desirable to be able to forecast the macro to improve your investment results, but the big question is can you do it? Can it be done? Marks said that he personally doesn't believe that you can be consistently superior in macro judgements. The two key words are consistently superior.
He also noted that the smartest investors from Buffett on down don't make macro judgements; they find great values to invest in.
He was asked what he thought will happen in Europe (just after telling them that forecasting macro can't be done consistently). He said that it is a complex situation but he is sure of three things:
1. He doesn't know what will happen in Europe
2. Nobody knows what will happen in Europe
3. If you ask an expert what they think and take their advice, you're making a mistake.
He quoted Mark Twain: "It's not what you don't know that gets you into trouble, it's what you know for certain that just ain't true".
Can you know more than others? That's the real question.
Julian Robertson on Macro
Interestingly, Julian Robertson too was on Bloomberg TV in June and it was really interesting to hear him say something similar to Marks. Someone asked him about the Europe situation and the macro environment and Robertson said that the macro situation is always tough to call. And he said that the problem with hedge fund performance has been stock selection and not macro.
If you look at the performance of hedge funds and stock funds over the past few years, I would bet that the performance has been much more influenced by stock selection than market-timing. Guys like Bill Ackman and Buffett's recent hires have done very well in the recent past while other value funds have done horribly and it's not due to one of them getting out of stocks before the crisis and getting back in right at the low. They didn't do better because of their macro insight.
Of course, there are guys out there that specialize in macro. One big fund these days is Bridgewater Associates that pretty much make all of their money on macro. I suppose Bill Gross at Pimco is like that too. George Soros is another that has made a lot of money over the years doing macro trading/investing.
But these people do macro full time and it's their specialty. This is a lot different than a value investor who raises cash due to economic uncertainty and trying to enhance their returns through this macro 'insight'.
Marks on Best Opportunities Now
Marks was asked where he sees the best opportunities now and he said real estate and real estate debt. He said that people are staying away from the area and in terms of deal flow he sees a lot of opportunity there.
Like other value managers, he also likes residential real estate. He said it's a good idea to buy housing and housing related investments when the market is assuming that housing will never recover.
Most Important Point of Marks' Book
At the end of the interview, he was asked what is the most important point that he wants his readers to understand about investing. He said that he wants people to understand that it's not easy. He said that when he talked to Munger, Munger told him that none of this stuff is meant to be easy and anyone who thinks it is is stupid.
Source | The Brooklyn Investor | http://brooklyninvestor.blogspot.com/2012/07/howard-marks-on-macro-etc.html
Showing posts with label etc.. Show all posts
Showing posts with label etc.. Show all posts
Sunday, November 18, 2012
Wednesday, November 14, 2012
DF Spinoff, Mr. Market, When to Sell etc.
So it's been a while since I posted. Some late summer, beginning of the school-year business, some laziness and some dead-ends is my excuse.
Dean Foods / WhiteWave Foods Spinoff
I spent some time digging into the Dean Foods (DF) WhiteWave spinoff but couldn't get over the fact that it just looks like a really crappy business. Sure, sales have been growing at WhiteWave in double-digits which is rare in the food industry, but their operating margins is in the high single digits; much lower than other branded goods. It was hard for me to give it a high multiple which would be needed to make this an interesting sum-of-the-parts/spinoff play.
Maybe WhiteWave after the spin improves operations and gets their margins up, but they didn't really indicate that on their recent conference call. I think they have said in the past that high single digits is the normalized operating margin they expect over time at WhiteWave and when an analyst asked if that is still the case in a post-spin-announcement conference call, they said they don't want to comment on that now. So my take is, why would it change after the spin?
Looking around in stores, I wonder what the moat is in the WhiteWave business. Most of the brands are relatively new, and I think that it's the concept of non-dairy milk that is the attraction, not so much the brand name itself. For example, if I was going to buy soy milk, does it have to be "Silk"? I wonder about that.
Not to mention all the debt that these guys have to deal with. In any case, having looked at this for a while, I didn't come up with anything interesting enough to merit a whole post. If things change, I may post something on it later.
Mr. Market
When I was looking at asset managers to come up with comps in a recent post (the OAK post), I came across GAMCO Investors (GBL). Of course, we all know Mario Gabelli, a bubblevision regular and long time Barron's roundtable member. GBL has been listed for a while too and has been talked about over the years. I've always paid attention to what Gabelli has to say but never really looked that closely at GBL. It still seems like an OK stock, nothing really exciting.
But what was interesting is that in the last few years, Gabelli has this excerpt from the Intelligent Investor at the beginning of his annual reports.
Imagine that in some private business you own a small share that cost you ,000. One of your partners, named Mr. Market, is very obliging indeed. Every day he tells you what he thinks your interest is worth and furthermore offers either to buy you out or sell you an additional interest on that basis. Sometimes his idea of value appears plausible and justified by business developments and prospects as you know them. Often, on the other hand, Mr. Market lets his enthusiasm or his fears run away with him, and the value he proposes seems to you a little short of silly.
If you are a prudent investor or a sensible businessman, will you let Mr. Market's daily communication determine your view of the value of a ,000 interest in the enterprise? Only in case you agree with him, or in case you want to trade with him. You may be happy to sell out to him when he quotes you a ridiculously high price, and equally happy to buy from him when his price is low. But the rest of the time you will be wiser to form your own ideas of the value of your holdings, based on full reports from the company about its operations and financial position.- Benjamin Graham, The Intelligent Investor
This is nothing new. We all talk about Mr. Market all the time, but I do think that sometimes people forget about that. For example, all the complaining about high-frequency traders, market distortions due to leveraged ETFs, hedge funds making markets more volatile, the frustration with the "risk on/ risk off" modes of the market (which reminds me of the "inflation day / deflation day" markets not too long ago) makes me wonder if we forgot that Mr. Market is irrational. It doesn't matter what form it takes; in one era they were daytraders and SOES bandits, in another it was the index arbitrage and portfolio insuring delta hedgers using futures. How about the days (before my time) when markets moved based on money supply figures published on Thursday nights? Now the players are different, but still irrational.
We need these people as value investors. We need people to be trading stocks based on things other than fundamental values. Value investors love people who sell a stock because it breaks below support and think it will go lower and buy stock as it gets more expensive.
Without these people, who will we sell to and buy from? The crazier and more insane Mr. Market is, the better it is for the value investor, as long as they are not leveraged and have their fate dependent on the generosity of a prime broker.
Interesting Conversation
I was at Barnes and Noble the other day (I am such a boring person that nothing to me is as exciting as browsing a bookstore. Oh, getting a fresh-off-the-press annual report in the mailbox is actually a little more exciting) and was wandering around in the business/finance section. This particular bookstore was near some major financial firms so had a larger than normal finance section.
Anyway, I overheard an interesting conversation. I almost jumped in but thought better of it and quickly walked away.
The conversation was between some young, pimple-faced kid (maybe early to mid 20s) and a young middle-eastern looking kid of around the same age.
I heard the young kid tell the middle-eastern kid that he runs a macro hedge fund (this reminds me of another time when young kids seemed to jump into something!). He said why bother with stocks? If you buy a stock you like, like a consumer staple, the stock can go down because of what happens in Europe even if it has nothing to do with the company you own. Why bother with stocks then? It makes no sense to own something where the stock price is impacted by factors that have nothing to do with the business. So therefore, he explained, he primarily buys and sells corporate bonds, government bonds and foreign currencies.
Well, OK. I was tempted to jump in with my thoughts, but I know how these conversations tend to go so I just thought better of it.
This reminds me of the Lind Waldock TV commercials not too far back. The commercial was similar to the above conversation. Some lady was talking to some guy and she says, why bother with stocks? With stocks you have problems like p/e ratios and corporate scandals. Why bother with that? Just stick to what you know, like coffee and crude oil.
As much as I am a fan of free speech and free market capitalism, I thought that was awful; to try to convince people in TV commercials that speculating in commodity futures is safer than investing in stocks.
Anyway, this conversation reminded me of the above Mr. Market story. We should love that markets go up and down for the wrong reasons.
When to Sell
So someone asked me when it's a good time to sell after buying a stock. That's a really good question. In the investing world, sometimes it's harder to figure out when to sell rather than when to buy.
For someone like Buffett or other super-long term investors, this is not an issue as his favorite holding period is "forever". In that case, when to sell is not an issue (even though he regrets not selling Coke in the late 90s).
There are many reasons to sell. An investment can be a mistake, an error in analysis etc. Things can change at the company for the worse and it can turn into something that is different than what you initially imagined. But I would advocate never selling due to short term concerns about the economy or next quarter's earnings.
Otherwise, if you buy something thinking it's worth 0 at , you typically would want to sell it at or 0.
But is it always that simple? What if the company is growing at 10%/year and you think this is sustainable. Wouldn't it be OK to hold it even at fair value if that fair value is growing at 10%/year? I would say yes, assuming the intrinsic value calculation is conservative.
If what you own is an excellent company with great management with a great track record, I would be inclined to own it even at fair value or above. How many people would have sold out of Berkshire Hathaway years ago after making money on it? Maybe someone bought it at in the 1970s and sold it at 0 or even a whopping 0 (now trading, as we know, at 0,000/share). Surely some people bought at and sold at 0 for the best trade in their investment lives.
A recent example is AAPL; I remember a good friend kicking himself for patting himself on the back with Apple. I think he bought it at and sold out at . Homerun! He was complaining about this trade when it was at around .
Apple is not a great example because I too didn't see this coming either; after every hit product I wondered what the next thing will be. I was late into the game and did well on it, but I don't know that AAPL is a company that will sustain their edge for the next ten or twenty years.
So back to the question; if I bought a stock because I thought it was cheap, then I would sell it when it is no longer cheap unless it is one of those 'great' companies that I want to own over the very long term.
Comparing to alternatives is also a good idea. If you buy a stock for 60% of intrinsic value and then sell it at 90% of intrinsic value, where do you put that money? Is there another stock trading at 60% of intrinsic value? Is intrinsic value growing at a pace that makes owning the stock close to intrinsic value attractive?
Sometimes owning a company that is growing intrinsic value at 10%/year at intrinsic value is better than owning a non-growing company at 60% of intrinsic value, unless there is reason to believe that the discount to intrinsic value will close relatively soon. This really all depends.
Greenblatt's book (The Little Book That Beats the Market) has shown that stock prices do routinely get undervalued, and really cheap stocks tend to get back to higher values in a year, so focusing on what something is worth should still be the primary goal (again, except for when structuring permanent, long term portfolios).
This is interesting because in his other book, I think he said that some of his best investments took two or three years before it really took off (I think he was talking about spinoffs).
When to Buy
And this leads to the other question; when to buy? People are so concerned about all sorts of things that they don't want to own stocks. So if you don't buy a stock you like now because of worries about a European implosion, the fiscal cliff or the elections, then when do you buy? If these uncertainties clear, wouldn't stock prices actually be higher? Yes, if the nightmare(s) are realized, stock prices can also be materially lower.
So if you get out of stocks now to buy back in later when it feels better, then the math that has to be done is: What are the odds that the negative scenarios unfold? What are the odds that stock prices go down because of that? And then what are the odds that you will have the courage to be able to buy stocks when it goes down?
I was going to pull out some old spreadsheets and actually calculate the economic value of owning cash right now in front of all of these uncertainties. You can use exotic option pricing models to see what the value of holding cash now is and waiting for a market decline. This can be compared to just owning stocks now and what the long term expected return is based on the current price (down-and-in knock-in call options, lookback call option (where call buyer gets to choose lowest price in certain period etc...) pricing models can be used to calculate the theoretical value of this optionality).
But it's a hassle, so maybe I'll do it one of these days but not today.
The point is, if you can buy a stock now with an expected return of, say, 10%, that's great. It's probably better to forget about what can happen between now and the medium to long term. Who cares?
If you know that the business will grow 10% per year and the stock price will move up with that, who cares if there is a crash in October that would allow you to buy it 20% cheaper then. In fact, if you plan on holding the stock for a long time, then the 20% discount isn't even that important; if you plan to hold something for 10 years, a 20% discount will bump up your annualized return from 10% to 12.5%. Over 20 years, a 20% discount will bump up your return from 10% to 11.2%.
Of course, 2.5% is not trivial. Over time, that compounds meaningfully. But the point here is that the other side of the equation is that the 20% discount may not come and the stock can run away.
As I keep saying again and again, if you go back to the beginning of the year and gave someone just the headlines throughout the year 2012, nobody would guess the market would be where it is now...
This is not to say that we should all be 100% fully invested. As Greenblatt said in a column at his website (that I can't find there anymore), one should own as much stocks as one can stand to watch it go down 50% because the stock market *will* go down 50% every now and then. The mistake people made in 2008/2009 wasn't that they didn't get out in time. It was that they owned too much for their own comfort so they sold out in fear at the lows to make their losses permanent.
Also, Buffett has said many times that he has never not invested in something because of his or someone else's outlook on the economy, macro risks or anything like that.
OK, anyway, this was another meandering post but at least I put something up.
I hope to be more active going forward with some interesting things to look at.
Source | The Brooklyn Investor | http://brooklyninvestor.blogspot.com/2012/09/df-spinoff-mr-market-when-to-sell-etc.html
Labels:
etc.,
Investor Guide,
Market,
Sell,
Spinoff
Tuesday, November 13, 2012
The Big Secret, Magic Formula, WisdomTree etc.
I just finished reading The Big Secret for the Small Investor, and thought it was really good. I know, I know. This is old news. It's been blogged and discussed to death, I think. But I haven't kept up with my reading and I just happened to come across this at the local library so I checked it out.
I don't know how much professional investors would get out of it as there is not much new in here other than the idea of using a value-weighted index to outperform other index types (even though I really enjoyed reading it).
Here is the blurb from the book on ways individuals can manage their money:
Valuing a Business
Greenblatt is a great writer and he really describes well how a business should be looked at, how it should be valued etc. He also explains really well why most people and money managers can't outperform the market (chasing performance etc). This section alone is worth a lot for novice investors and people starting out, and it's even great for pros to refresh themselves on what they're trying to do.
Importance of Owning Stocks
He also does a great job explaining why most people should put a substantial amount of their net worth in stocks. But he also says that that doesn't mean people should be 100% in equities all the time; like he said in his essay, people should own as much stock as they can tolerate the occasional (and inevitable) 50% decline in the market (which nobody will be able to market-time in and out of consistently). He provides a tip for avoiding the emotional traps of investing (just keep a constant ratio in stocks at all times, bull or bear market. And don't try to time it as that is one of the biggest factors in causing people to underperform!).
Indexing
In the book, he explains that most money managers can't outperform the S&P 500 index, so he starts there and then improves on the S&P 500 index step-by-step finally arriving at the value-weighted index.
Value-weighted Indexing
The problem with traditional indexing is that you end up owning more of the most expensive stocks (and large cap) and less of the smaller, cheaper stocks. Greenblatt explains that this is why equal-weighted indices tend to outperform over time compared to market-cap weighted indices (such as the S&P 500 index). Equal-weighted indices put the same amount of money in each stock regardless of market-cap so this bias goes away.
He also explains that fundamental-weighted indexing tends to outperform the market-cap weighted indices for the same reason; it doesn't own more of the bigger cap and more overvalued stocks, but weights the index according to some fundamental factor like dividends, earnings, sales or some such thing. So it eliminates the bias of owning more of something overvalued. (It would still have a large cap bias as you would still end up owning more of a big company than a small company based on fundamental factors).
Greenblatt's solution is an improvement on all of the above. Since Greenblatt is a value investor, he is most interested in value. So therefore, instead of using something arbitrary like market capitalization to weight an index, or something a bit more meaningful like fundamental factors, why not just weight the index based on valuation? Own more of something undervalued and less of something overvalued.
That makes total sense, and he has shown in his other book ("The Little Book That Beats the Market") that valuation matters and works.
Data
Greenblatt set up a website for this book and here is some of the data posted there. The website is:
http://valueweightedindex.com/
Check out the results of using a value-weighted index:
Pretty impressive. If the figures are too small, you can just go to the website and see all of these figures.
I know many people will be skeptical of this and say that the index was probably optimized somehow. But Greenblatt is a real money manager and he is not out there doing stuff to make money off of selling books. He understands that the problem with these 'models' is backfitting / over-optimizing (that's why the Magic Formula is so simple; just two factors. He knows he can improve on them by testing various factors and weights, but then the model wouldn't be as robust. What is so impressive about the magic formula is how simple it is and how consistent the results tend to be over time).
But the Problem is...
So we can read this book and go, what a great idea! And then what? Where do we buy value-weighted index funds? Alas, there aren't any. In the book (and at the website), he directs us to equal-weighted index funds and fundamental-weighted index funds and some value-based ETFs (which is not the same idea Greenblatt describes), but there are no value-weighted funds.
I guess Greenblatt is hoping to push the ETF industry into creating them so he wouldn't have to do it himself. He is obviously more interested in teaching than trying to make money off of his ideas.
But What About the Magic Formula (MF)?
There has been a lot of talk about the MF on blogs, websites and whatnot, how it works or it doesn't work etc. But for the most part, I tend to think the time period has been too short to make any real evaluation, not to mention the fact that we had a huge financial crisis since then.
As Greenblatt has said himself, the MF can underperform for long periods of time. This is precisely why it will continue to keep working over time. If something works too well and too consistently in every time period, then it would probably very soon stop working (think of those "I can guarantee you 1%/month consistently with less volatility than the S&P 500 index!". How long did that last?).
In the case of the MF, Greenblatt did set up a company to invest using their method and they do have mutual funds available.
Here's the website:
http://www.formulainvesting.com/
And here's a composite index of returns based on the strategy from the website:
This is way too short a time period to evaluate returns so this may not be too meaningful.
But as a way to invest money, I am a big believer in this approach. I would bet that over long periods of time, this approach would outperform the index and most money managers.
So Which Mutual Fund is Better?
Formula Investing runs four mutual funds (with small minimums):
So what's the difference? The "Select" funds invest in 75-120 names whereas the Value 1000 (and 400 for the International) invests in 1,000 names.
I think if you want to see the MF work, it's going to be more pronounced with fewer names. With a 1,000 stock portfolio, I can't imagine it diverging too far from the index. Of course, Greenblatt suggests in his book that 20-30 names (the MF results in the The Little Book That Beats the Market is based on a 30 stock portfolio. I initially wrote 8-10 names here, but that was wrong) is enough diversification, but that's not going to work for an open-end mutual fund.
So I would go with the "Select" funds.
U.S. or International? Right now since the International funds seem to be performing so horribly, and since the problems on the planet seems more focused around the world ex-U.S., I would tend to lean towards the International. Isn't this where the values would be?
I know we are all pretty confident that China and Europe is going to implode. It's a no-brainer right now to be out of those countries. But that's sort of the whole purpose of value investing, especially the mechanical kind where we override emotions, right? To go in when nobody want to. Greenblatt did say in a presentation not too long ago that any time you look at the list of values that the MF website spits out, most people would hate those names. There would be good, sound, rational reasons why you wouldn't want to own those names. But that's precisely the reason why those names are on that list, and that's why the MF tends to outperform.
So on that basis, I would go with the ugly-looking International Select fund, out of the above Formula Investing funds. But if you decide to do that, don't look at what the fund owns. I guarantee you that you will change your mind. You will say, "yuck!" and not get into the fund. Also, I can guarantee you that the week after you buy into it, something will happen and the NAV of the fund will plunge. Then you will kick yourself for reading something on a blog. But don't worry. If you decide to buy, don't worry about what it does over the next month or even year (If you are going to worry about short term performance, then just don't buy it!).
Or how about some sort of balanced approach? Keep a constant percentage in each of U.S. and International, and then rebalance every now and then so that you would sell the one that did well and buy the one that did less well (so you sell dear and buy cheap). But there may be costs associated with that so I don't know. It's just a thought. I don't do anything with mutual funds myself, and when I did own them, I tended never to rebalance anything.
Anyway, I have no problem at all recommending these funds to friends and family members etc. for their equity exposure. I am that comfortable with the approach of these funds and the people involved (Greenblatt).
So having said that, if you are friend or family and are reading this, look through your equity mutual fund holdings and if you own anything that is blah, some fund you own that you bought for a reason you don't remember and it's so-so or worse, then get rid of those and roll it into one of these funds. If you own mutual funds that you like, though, and is doing well, there is no reason to dump those.
I know most people tend to accumulate too many different mutual funds and stocks (as they are sold to them by various people. Most of these things sounded like good ideas at one time or another. But for some reason, people tend to buy stuff and never sell so they have this sort of financial attic of stocks and funds collecting dust. When you look carefully, sometimes you say, "What the...?").
If that's you, then clear some of that stuff out and just invest in one of these funds. You will do better.
Magic Formula or Value Weighted Index?
As far as mutual funds go, only Formula Investing exists, and according to the Value Weighted Indexing website, there really isn't a fund to invest with the "Big Secret" approach. So this isn't really a choice.
But if we had to make a choice, I would tend to favor a more concentrated Magic Formula approach since it would have fewer names and therefore potentially higher alpha. A value-weighted index fund would have many names in the portfolio so maybe a more limited alpha (even though the outperformance of the value-weighted index in the above table is pretty substantial).
These Won't Ever Be Popular
By the way, these approaches, whether it's the MF or value-weighted index won't really get popular. Why? Because it's not good for the 'industry'. With all these mutual funds companies with armies of analysts and portfolio managers including 'stars', why would they push hard to point out that they can't outperform the S&P 500 over time, and then advertise something that even beats the S&P 500 index?
Why would brokers push these on clients? If they did, they would never be able to convince clients to sell them to buy into whatever the next big thing is (and earn commissions).
(This reminds me of a conversation I had with a broker trying to get my business many years ago. I told her that I had all my money in Berkshire Hathaway (I didn't own any at the time so I lied...) and that Buffett works for me for 0,000/year and he has a great track record over decades. No front-end loads, back-end loads, 12b-1 fees or any other such nonsense. Does she have any funds like that? Does following analyst recommendations and buying their IPOs lead to Buffett-like performance? Why do I need a broker when Warren does all the work for me, and I bet his broker is better than any broker I can hope to find. Of course, she never called again: mission accomplished.)
Or How About Something Else?
And here's an interesting twist to this whole thing. It is often much more profitable to invest in a money manager than in the funds they themselves manage (even if the funds perform very well). This is due to the operating leverage that the fund management company enjoys and the added kicker of revenue growth above and beyond investment performance due to asset accumulation.
So even if the stock market only returns 5%/year going forward, if they have net inflows that amounts to 5% of AUM, that would lead to a 10%/year growth in revenues. With constant margins, earnings would grow faster than the market and if the valuation is unchanged, the value of the fund management company grows faster than the stock market.
That's one layer of the leverage. But then you have the operating leverage too. If AUM grows in existing funds or the marginal cost of launching new funds is low, then operating margins can go up as AUM increases. So that adds another potential kicker to the valuation of a fund management company.
This doesn't always work. I think in many of the recently IPO'ed private equity and hedge funds, the AUM growth seems to come primarily from launching new strategies (that usually entails acquisitions of whole portfolio management teams that run the new strategy), so the operating leverage doesn't really kick in as much.
WisdomTree Investments (WETF)
So this naturally leads to WisdomTree Investments. The hedge fund legend Michael Steinhardt owns a big chunk of this thing so he is obviously a big believer in the fundamental-weighted index concept. Who knows, maybe WETF will eventually launch value-weighted index funds.
Anyway, I was going to take a quick look at WETF in this post, but since this is already getting long I will make this another separate post. As a preview, I will say that it is an interesting company but doesn't look particularly cheap to me at this point unless AUM continues to grow at a high pace.

Source | The Brooklyn Investor | http://brooklyninvestor.blogspot.com/2012/09/the-big-secret-magic-formula-wisdomtree.html
I don't know how much professional investors would get out of it as there is not much new in here other than the idea of using a value-weighted index to outperform other index types (even though I really enjoyed reading it).
Here is the blurb from the book on ways individuals can manage their money:
- They can do it themselves. Trillions of dollars are invested this way. (Of course, the only problem here is that most people have no idea how to analyze and choose individual stocks. Well, not really the only problem. Most investors have no idea how to construct a stock portfolio, most have no idea when to buy and sell, and most have no idea how much to invest in the first place.)
- They can give it to professionals to invest. Trillions of dollars are invested this way.(Unfortunately most professionals actually underperform the market averages over time. In fact,it may be even harder to pick good professional managers than it is to pick good individual stocks.)
- They can invest in traditional index funds. Trillions of dollars are also invested this way.(The problem is that investing this way is seriously flawed--and almost a guarantee of subpar investment returns over time.)
- They can read The Big Secret for the Small Investor and do something else. Not much is invested this way. Yet...
Valuing a Business
Greenblatt is a great writer and he really describes well how a business should be looked at, how it should be valued etc. He also explains really well why most people and money managers can't outperform the market (chasing performance etc). This section alone is worth a lot for novice investors and people starting out, and it's even great for pros to refresh themselves on what they're trying to do.
Importance of Owning Stocks
He also does a great job explaining why most people should put a substantial amount of their net worth in stocks. But he also says that that doesn't mean people should be 100% in equities all the time; like he said in his essay, people should own as much stock as they can tolerate the occasional (and inevitable) 50% decline in the market (which nobody will be able to market-time in and out of consistently). He provides a tip for avoiding the emotional traps of investing (just keep a constant ratio in stocks at all times, bull or bear market. And don't try to time it as that is one of the biggest factors in causing people to underperform!).
Indexing
In the book, he explains that most money managers can't outperform the S&P 500 index, so he starts there and then improves on the S&P 500 index step-by-step finally arriving at the value-weighted index.
Value-weighted Indexing
The problem with traditional indexing is that you end up owning more of the most expensive stocks (and large cap) and less of the smaller, cheaper stocks. Greenblatt explains that this is why equal-weighted indices tend to outperform over time compared to market-cap weighted indices (such as the S&P 500 index). Equal-weighted indices put the same amount of money in each stock regardless of market-cap so this bias goes away.
He also explains that fundamental-weighted indexing tends to outperform the market-cap weighted indices for the same reason; it doesn't own more of the bigger cap and more overvalued stocks, but weights the index according to some fundamental factor like dividends, earnings, sales or some such thing. So it eliminates the bias of owning more of something overvalued. (It would still have a large cap bias as you would still end up owning more of a big company than a small company based on fundamental factors).
Greenblatt's solution is an improvement on all of the above. Since Greenblatt is a value investor, he is most interested in value. So therefore, instead of using something arbitrary like market capitalization to weight an index, or something a bit more meaningful like fundamental factors, why not just weight the index based on valuation? Own more of something undervalued and less of something overvalued.
That makes total sense, and he has shown in his other book ("The Little Book That Beats the Market") that valuation matters and works.
Data
Greenblatt set up a website for this book and here is some of the data posted there. The website is:
http://valueweightedindex.com/
Check out the results of using a value-weighted index:
Pretty impressive. If the figures are too small, you can just go to the website and see all of these figures.
I know many people will be skeptical of this and say that the index was probably optimized somehow. But Greenblatt is a real money manager and he is not out there doing stuff to make money off of selling books. He understands that the problem with these 'models' is backfitting / over-optimizing (that's why the Magic Formula is so simple; just two factors. He knows he can improve on them by testing various factors and weights, but then the model wouldn't be as robust. What is so impressive about the magic formula is how simple it is and how consistent the results tend to be over time).
But the Problem is...
So we can read this book and go, what a great idea! And then what? Where do we buy value-weighted index funds? Alas, there aren't any. In the book (and at the website), he directs us to equal-weighted index funds and fundamental-weighted index funds and some value-based ETFs (which is not the same idea Greenblatt describes), but there are no value-weighted funds.
I guess Greenblatt is hoping to push the ETF industry into creating them so he wouldn't have to do it himself. He is obviously more interested in teaching than trying to make money off of his ideas.
But What About the Magic Formula (MF)?
There has been a lot of talk about the MF on blogs, websites and whatnot, how it works or it doesn't work etc. But for the most part, I tend to think the time period has been too short to make any real evaluation, not to mention the fact that we had a huge financial crisis since then.
As Greenblatt has said himself, the MF can underperform for long periods of time. This is precisely why it will continue to keep working over time. If something works too well and too consistently in every time period, then it would probably very soon stop working (think of those "I can guarantee you 1%/month consistently with less volatility than the S&P 500 index!". How long did that last?).
In the case of the MF, Greenblatt did set up a company to invest using their method and they do have mutual funds available.
Here's the website:
http://www.formulainvesting.com/
And here's a composite index of returns based on the strategy from the website:
This is way too short a time period to evaluate returns so this may not be too meaningful.
But as a way to invest money, I am a big believer in this approach. I would bet that over long periods of time, this approach would outperform the index and most money managers.
So Which Mutual Fund is Better?
Formula Investing runs four mutual funds (with small minimums):
- U.S. Value 1000
- U.S. Value Select
- International Value 400
- International Value Select
So what's the difference? The "Select" funds invest in 75-120 names whereas the Value 1000 (and 400 for the International) invests in 1,000 names.
I think if you want to see the MF work, it's going to be more pronounced with fewer names. With a 1,000 stock portfolio, I can't imagine it diverging too far from the index. Of course, Greenblatt suggests in his book that 20-30 names (the MF results in the The Little Book That Beats the Market is based on a 30 stock portfolio. I initially wrote 8-10 names here, but that was wrong) is enough diversification, but that's not going to work for an open-end mutual fund.
So I would go with the "Select" funds.
U.S. or International? Right now since the International funds seem to be performing so horribly, and since the problems on the planet seems more focused around the world ex-U.S., I would tend to lean towards the International. Isn't this where the values would be?
I know we are all pretty confident that China and Europe is going to implode. It's a no-brainer right now to be out of those countries. But that's sort of the whole purpose of value investing, especially the mechanical kind where we override emotions, right? To go in when nobody want to. Greenblatt did say in a presentation not too long ago that any time you look at the list of values that the MF website spits out, most people would hate those names. There would be good, sound, rational reasons why you wouldn't want to own those names. But that's precisely the reason why those names are on that list, and that's why the MF tends to outperform.
So on that basis, I would go with the ugly-looking International Select fund, out of the above Formula Investing funds. But if you decide to do that, don't look at what the fund owns. I guarantee you that you will change your mind. You will say, "yuck!" and not get into the fund. Also, I can guarantee you that the week after you buy into it, something will happen and the NAV of the fund will plunge. Then you will kick yourself for reading something on a blog. But don't worry. If you decide to buy, don't worry about what it does over the next month or even year (If you are going to worry about short term performance, then just don't buy it!).
Or how about some sort of balanced approach? Keep a constant percentage in each of U.S. and International, and then rebalance every now and then so that you would sell the one that did well and buy the one that did less well (so you sell dear and buy cheap). But there may be costs associated with that so I don't know. It's just a thought. I don't do anything with mutual funds myself, and when I did own them, I tended never to rebalance anything.
Anyway, I have no problem at all recommending these funds to friends and family members etc. for their equity exposure. I am that comfortable with the approach of these funds and the people involved (Greenblatt).
So having said that, if you are friend or family and are reading this, look through your equity mutual fund holdings and if you own anything that is blah, some fund you own that you bought for a reason you don't remember and it's so-so or worse, then get rid of those and roll it into one of these funds. If you own mutual funds that you like, though, and is doing well, there is no reason to dump those.
I know most people tend to accumulate too many different mutual funds and stocks (as they are sold to them by various people. Most of these things sounded like good ideas at one time or another. But for some reason, people tend to buy stuff and never sell so they have this sort of financial attic of stocks and funds collecting dust. When you look carefully, sometimes you say, "What the...?").
If that's you, then clear some of that stuff out and just invest in one of these funds. You will do better.
Magic Formula or Value Weighted Index?
As far as mutual funds go, only Formula Investing exists, and according to the Value Weighted Indexing website, there really isn't a fund to invest with the "Big Secret" approach. So this isn't really a choice.
But if we had to make a choice, I would tend to favor a more concentrated Magic Formula approach since it would have fewer names and therefore potentially higher alpha. A value-weighted index fund would have many names in the portfolio so maybe a more limited alpha (even though the outperformance of the value-weighted index in the above table is pretty substantial).
These Won't Ever Be Popular
By the way, these approaches, whether it's the MF or value-weighted index won't really get popular. Why? Because it's not good for the 'industry'. With all these mutual funds companies with armies of analysts and portfolio managers including 'stars', why would they push hard to point out that they can't outperform the S&P 500 over time, and then advertise something that even beats the S&P 500 index?
Why would brokers push these on clients? If they did, they would never be able to convince clients to sell them to buy into whatever the next big thing is (and earn commissions).
(This reminds me of a conversation I had with a broker trying to get my business many years ago. I told her that I had all my money in Berkshire Hathaway (I didn't own any at the time so I lied...) and that Buffett works for me for 0,000/year and he has a great track record over decades. No front-end loads, back-end loads, 12b-1 fees or any other such nonsense. Does she have any funds like that? Does following analyst recommendations and buying their IPOs lead to Buffett-like performance? Why do I need a broker when Warren does all the work for me, and I bet his broker is better than any broker I can hope to find. Of course, she never called again: mission accomplished.)
Or How About Something Else?
And here's an interesting twist to this whole thing. It is often much more profitable to invest in a money manager than in the funds they themselves manage (even if the funds perform very well). This is due to the operating leverage that the fund management company enjoys and the added kicker of revenue growth above and beyond investment performance due to asset accumulation.
So even if the stock market only returns 5%/year going forward, if they have net inflows that amounts to 5% of AUM, that would lead to a 10%/year growth in revenues. With constant margins, earnings would grow faster than the market and if the valuation is unchanged, the value of the fund management company grows faster than the stock market.
That's one layer of the leverage. But then you have the operating leverage too. If AUM grows in existing funds or the marginal cost of launching new funds is low, then operating margins can go up as AUM increases. So that adds another potential kicker to the valuation of a fund management company.
This doesn't always work. I think in many of the recently IPO'ed private equity and hedge funds, the AUM growth seems to come primarily from launching new strategies (that usually entails acquisitions of whole portfolio management teams that run the new strategy), so the operating leverage doesn't really kick in as much.
WisdomTree Investments (WETF)
So this naturally leads to WisdomTree Investments. The hedge fund legend Michael Steinhardt owns a big chunk of this thing so he is obviously a big believer in the fundamental-weighted index concept. Who knows, maybe WETF will eventually launch value-weighted index funds.
Anyway, I was going to take a quick look at WETF in this post, but since this is already getting long I will make this another separate post. As a preview, I will say that it is an interesting company but doesn't look particularly cheap to me at this point unless AUM continues to grow at a high pace.
Source | The Brooklyn Investor | http://brooklyninvestor.blogspot.com/2012/09/the-big-secret-magic-formula-wisdomtree.html
Labels:
etc.,
Formula,
Investor Guide,
Magic,
Secret,
WisdomTree
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)